Supervisor, Social Creative

New York City, NY (Hybrid)

$91K/yr – $141K/yrSenior Level6+ years expFull time

Posted 3 hrs ago

Job Summary

Own and scale GEICO's social content team by delivering high-quality content at speed, guiding strategy-to-production, and aligning cross-functional workstreams with Brand, Product, and performance goals.

  • Lead hiring and onboarding to support team growth
  • Translate strategic priorities into actionable production plans

Job Description

Responsibilities

  • Directly manage and develop a team of content producers and copywriters, setting clear expectations for output, quality, and growth.
  • Coach producers on craft, platform fluency, and creative judgment; coach copywriters on brand voice, tone, and platform-appropriate writing.
  • Prioritize and sequence the team's workload across concurrent requests from Brand, Product, Organic Social, and Paid Social.
  • Support hiring and onboarding as the team grows, including freelance or contractor support for peak production needs.
  • Write, review, and approve content concepts, scripts, copy, and final cuts before they reach stakeholders or go live.
  • Set and maintain the creative and editorial bar across all social content and copy, balancing speed with quality.
  • Lead a new era of GEICO social content output, including developing recurring content series.
  • Resolve creative disagreements and make the final call when the team and stakeholders don't align.
  • Determine when content or copy needs sign-off and when the team can move independently.
  • Translate strategic priorities from the MLT and goals into a clear production plan for the team.

Requirements

  • Experience: 6+ years creating social content or copy, including direct experience managing or leading a team.
  • Service Company Context: Experience working inside a conversion-driven service business — financial services, insurance, SaaS, or banking — where marketing is tied directly to customer acquisition and retention.
  • Production & Copy Fluency: Hands-on experience with both social-first video production and short-form copywriting, fluent across TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube Shorts.
  • People Leadership: Demonstrated experience managing, coaching, or mentoring a mixed team of creative and editorial talent.
  • Cross-Functional Fluency: Experience partnering with Brand, Product, and Organic and Paid Social teams to translate business goals into creative and editorial output.
  • Tools: Familiarity with mobile production and editing tools such as CapCut, Premiere Pro, Final Cut, or After Effects, and with copy workflows; comfort with AI tools like Claude or Copilot to speed up your own and your team's output.

Preferred

  • Experience managing a blended team of producers and copywriters specifically, not just one discipline.
  • Experience managing freelance or contractor support for peak production needs.
  • Background coordinating live event or field content coverage logistics.
  • Experience with motion graphics, animation, or multi-platform campaign production.
  • Experience developing and launching recurring social content series or formats.

Benefits

  • Great Rewards: We offer compensation and benefits built to enhance your physical well-being, mental and emotional health, and financial future — including market-competitive compensation, a 401K savings plan vested from day one with a 6% match, performance and recognition-based incentives, tuition assistance, mental healthcare, fertility and adoption assistance, and the GEICO Flex program offering up to four weeks of remote work per year.
GEICO logo

GEICO

GEICO (Government Employees Insurance Company) offers a variety of insurance such as vehicle, property, business, life, umbrella, travel, pet, jewelry and more. The company, which was founded in 1936, is the third-largest auto insurer in the United States and insures vehicles in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. GEICO, a member of the Berkshire Hathaway family of companies, constantly strives to make lives better by protecting people against unexpected events while saving them money and providing an outstanding customer experience. Visit geico.com to learn more ▪️ Building a Diverse Workforce ▪️We are building a diverse and inclusive workforce. GEICO is dedicated to fostering a workplace where everyone feels valued, respected and supported. Our company is focused on building a diverse workforce through a culture of intentional inclusion. ▪️ Supporting Our Communities ▪️Our commitment to being an engaged and involved corporate citizen is important to us. We work with supportive partners across the country that help us provide resources for people in need. Authenticity and inclusiveness are paramount as we give back to our communities. ▪️GEICO Cares ▪️ Our employees can make a big impact by participating in company-wide social impact programs such as Giving Back Together and FastPitch. They can also volunteer with local and national organizations such as Shoes That Fit, Reading is Fundamental, and more. To learn more, visit GEICO in the Community. GEICO Has Office Locations In: Regional offices: •Buffalo, New York •Dallas, Texas •Fredericksburg, Virginia •Indianapolis, Indiana •Lakeland, Florida •Macon, Georgia •San Diego, California •Tucson, Arizona •Virginia Beach, Virginia •Woodbury, New York Service centers: •Honolulu, Hawaii •Kansas City, Kansas •Iowa City, Iowa Claims centers: •Houston, Texas •Marlton, New Jersey •Seattle, Washington Headquarters Chevy Chase, MD

Founded in 1936
Chevy Chase, Maryland, USA
31K employees (459 in marketing)

Salaries

Posted range

$91K/yr – $141K/yr

Taken straight from the job posting.

Creative median pay in the United States

$110K/yr

Most pay falls between $83K and $155K. Based on 2,754 salaries.

See all GEICO salaries

Traffic Signals

Monthly Visitors
13.1M
Traffic Source Mix
Search
31.3%
Direct
62.4%
Referral
4.3%
Social
0.2%
Paid
1.7%

Headcount Trend

Current headcount: ~31K
GEICO logo

Supervisor, Social Creative

GEICO · New York City, NY · Hybrid